đĄ En bref : ARTICLE đ° sur un nouveau critĂšre de crĂ©dibilitĂ©, la cohĂ©rence mnĂ©monique diffĂ©rentielle.
Titre : Truth in inconsistency? The potential of differential mnemonic consistency in deception detection
Auteurs : A. Philippsen, N. Brandenburg, R. Bell, A. Buchner
Résumé original : « Among both laypeople and law-enforcement personnel, the modal belief is that a lack of consistency across repeated statements signals that a testimony is fabricated. However, inconsistencies also occur in reports of events that have actually been experienced. This is taken into account by the concept of differential mnemonic consistency: Within an experience-based statement, certain elements of an event (e.g. core activities) should be reported more consistently across interviews than others (e.g. peripheral activities) whereas fabricated statements should largely lack this natural difference in mnemonic consistency. We tested this expectation experimentally by conducting two successive interviews with participants who either reported an experienced physical examination or fabricated a statement in which they pretended to have undergone the examination. Two measures of mnemonic consistency were used: retention consistency (an element reported in the first interview is re-reported in the second interview) and repetition consistency (an element reported in the second interview is a repetition of an element from the first interview). Differential mnemonic consistency distinguished reliably between experience-based and fabricated statements, but the distinction was even better with repetition consistency than with retention consistency as the consistency measure. Differential mnemonic consistency may thus be a promising criterion in credibility assessment. »
Date de parution : 19/11/2025
Ădition : Psychology, Crime & Law
DOI : 10.1080/1068316X.2025.2587165
ThĂšmes : EnquĂȘte, MĂ©moire, Victimologie, TĂ©moignage
Citer cette rĂ©fĂ©rence : Philippsen, A., Brandenburg, N., Bell, R., & Buchner, A. (2025). Truth in inconsistency? The potential of differential mnemonic consistency in deception detection. Psychology, Crime & Law, 1â21. https://doi.org/10.1080/1068316X.2025.2587165
RĂ©sumĂ© traduit en français : « Tant chez les profanes que chez les forces de lâordre, lâidĂ©e dominante est quâun manque de cohĂ©rence entre des dĂ©clarations rĂ©pĂ©tĂ©es indique quâun tĂ©moignage est inventĂ© de toutes piĂšces. Cependant, des incohĂ©rences apparaissent Ă©galement dans les rĂ©cits dâĂ©vĂ©nements rĂ©ellement vĂ©cus. Câest ce dont tient compte le concept de cohĂ©rence mnĂ©monique diffĂ©rentielle : dans un rĂ©cit fondĂ© sur une expĂ©rience vĂ©cue, certains Ă©lĂ©ments dâun Ă©vĂ©nement (par exemple, les activitĂ©s principales) devraient ĂȘtre rapportĂ©s de maniĂšre plus cohĂ©rente dâun entretien Ă lâautre que dâautres (par exemple, les activitĂ©s secondaires), tandis que les rĂ©cits inventĂ©s devraient, pour lâessentiel, ne pas prĂ©senter cette diffĂ©rence naturelle en termes de cohĂ©rence mnĂ©monique. Nous avons testĂ© cette hypothĂšse de maniĂšre expĂ©rimentale en menant deux entretiens successifs avec des participants qui, soit dĂ©claraient avoir subi un examen physique, soit inventaient un rĂ©cit dans lequel ils prĂ©tendaient avoir subi cet examen. Deux mesures de cohĂ©rence mnĂ©monique ont Ă©tĂ© utilisĂ©es : la cohĂ©rence de rĂ©tention (un Ă©lĂ©ment mentionnĂ© lors du premier entretien est Ă nouveau mentionnĂ© lors du deuxiĂšme) et la cohĂ©rence de rĂ©pĂ©tition (un Ă©lĂ©ment mentionnĂ© lors du deuxiĂšme entretien est une rĂ©pĂ©tition dâun Ă©lĂ©ment du premier entretien). La cohĂ©rence mnĂ©monique diffĂ©rentielle a permis de distinguer de maniĂšre fiable les dĂ©clarations fondĂ©es sur lâexpĂ©rience de celles inventĂ©es de toutes piĂšces, mais cette distinction Ă©tait encore plus nette lorsque lâon utilisait la cohĂ©rence de rĂ©pĂ©tition comme mesure de cohĂ©rence plutĂŽt que la cohĂ©rence de rĂ©tention. La cohĂ©rence mnĂ©monique diffĂ©rentielle pourrait donc constituer un critĂšre prometteur pour l’Ă©valuation de la crĂ©dibilitĂ©. »